The difference between speculating and investing

The difference between speculating and investing

During my three years working for a stockbroking firm I learnt the difference between being an investor and being a speculator. Responsible for setting up the retail trading desk I saw firsthand the mistakes many private clients made when it came to trading. Keep in mind that this was during the bubble in the late 90’s and companies were listing that should probably never have been allowed to, and which no longer exist today. Despite the dubious nature of both their businesses and directors, their initial public offering (IPOs) were oversubscribed and on the day of listing the share price invariably leapt up by at least ten percent.

If you could get in on the listing, it was guaranteed money – not because the companies themselves were worth anywhere near what they were listing at, but because there was blind greed and someone out there would be prepared to buy it from you at a higher price for no rational reason except for hoping that the next person would pay even more. Sound familiar?

It got to a point where people were using the seven-day settlement period to buy and sell shares within seven days, hoping to make a profit before they had to pay for those shares. Fortunately, I happened to work with a lot of grey-haired, experienced individuals who knew a bubble when they saw it. One of the smartest things our director did was to refuse to trade on a seven-day settlement unless the client had deposited money with us or had an existing share portfolio double the value of the trade. When the bubble burst spectacularly, both in the Russian financial crisis of 1998 and again with the bubble crash of 2000, our brokerage survived. Many did not because their clients were buying shares with money they didn’t have.

I was fortunate to work with people who taught me that the real power of investing came from dividends – not the share price. The focus of the portfolios they managed for their clients was on providing dividend income which is far more predictable and stable that the capital growth of a share. Many of those hastily patched together companies that were listed in the late 1990’s could not generate legitimate earnings to pay a dividend, so were never included in the portfolios. My mother’s portfolio was among those and I still remember when she called me one day and said “I don’t understand, all my friends are complaining that they have lost all their money in the market but I am still getting my monthly income, how is that possible?” Not only did my mother continue to receive her income (which increases ahead of inflation each year thanks to the fact that on average JSE listed companies increase their dividends by around 8% per annum) her capital value also survived the crashes, and many more, because high dividend stocks are by nature more defensive.

It was a great lesson to learn early in my investment career and it forms part of my investment philosophy which is best illustrated by my purchase of Standard Bank in February 2016. I noticed that Standard Bank had a dividend yield of 7% – this made no sense because if I put my money on deposit with the bank, I would receive only 5%. The high dividend yield suggested the share was seriously undervalued. I invested in it and within two months the share price was up 30%. Which is great from a capital point of view, but even better, by buying at the lower price I locked in a 7% income return which has a lower tax rate than interest income. Investing is about the long-term and over time it will better serve you than speculating on the short-term market exuberance.

Share your story and win

Maya on Money is partnering with Sanlam iTrade Online to encourage readers and investors to share their inspiring trading stories with #TradeMyWay. If your story is selected for publication, you will receive R2,000 in CASH! The overall winning story will win an extra R3,000 cash. Tell us your most inspiring story related to online share trading in an email of no longer than 600 words. Your story must inspire others to start trading or continue trading with new ideas. It can also include an interesting lesson you’ve learned trading shares. Send your email to

Do you also have an inspiring trading story? Share it with us and you could win! See the #TradeMyWay page for more information.

Article originally published on ‘Maya on Money‘.

No Comments

Post A Comment